Errata sheet/labnol.org

labnol (2015): Create eBooks from Wikipedia

https://labnol.org/internet/create-wikipedia-ebooks/25491

1Alternatively, you can open any Wikipedia page and choose Book Creator from the toolbox menu in the right sidebar.drifted
Real pathTools → Switch → Special:Book Book
No rewrite passed a literal run in 3 loops. Needs a human.
VerdictThe doc's words no longer work and no rewrite passed a literal run in 3 loops. Needs a human; evidence attached.
ReviewConfirmed. Real drift: Book Creator is no longer in the toolbox (Tools) menu. Kane reached the book page another way, but no rewrite passed a literal run in 3 loops, so Errata asks a human to write the fix. · pending approval
What Kane did
Literal failedaction · 18.3 cr · 80s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace
  2. click: Clicking Tools in the right sidebar toolbox menu
  3. wait: Waiting after checking the expanded toolbox menu
The run looked in the wrong menu, so the required Book Creator link was never available.
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Tools
Kane's screenshot at the end of the literal run
Kane's screenshot at the end of this run, from its sealed evidence pack
Follow these steps literally, one at a time, from the current page. Click only what each step names. Never type a URL, search, or take another route. Where to find them, in the tutorial's own words: "Alternatively, you can open any Wikipedia page and choose Book Creator from the toolbox menu in the right sidebar." 1. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Book Creator'. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
Goal passedtesting · 42.1 cr · 210s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace
  2. click: Clicking Tools to enable Book Creator for this article
  3. click: Clicking Switch to legacy parser in Wikipedia Book Creator tools
  4. wait: queued plan (2 steps): type "Search Wikipedia"; click "Search"
  5. type: Type "Special:Book" into "Search Wikipedia"
  6. click: Clicking Special:Book Book in Wikipedia Book Creator dropdown
  7. wait: PRIMARY: wait for the Ada Lovelace article to load
  8. wait: PRIMARY: wait after turning on Wikipedia's Book Creator for this article
  9. wait: PRIMARY: wait for the enabled Book Creator management page to load
  10. analyze: The page you end on has a main heading.
  11. assert: Wikipedia's Book Creator is on for this article.
  12. analyze: it is stored as {{landed_on}}
  13. wait: Waiting after the stored page location is verified
  14. wait: Waiting after confirming Wikipedia's Book Creator is enabled
enabled Book Creator on Wikipedia
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Tools → Switch → Special:Book Book
Kane's screenshot at the end of the goal run
Kane's screenshot at the end of this run, from its sealed evidence pack
Goal: wikipedia's book creator is on for this article. Reach it from the current page by clicking through the visible UI, by any route. Never type a URL or use the address bar. Hint: an old tutorial said "Alternatively, you can open any Wikipedia page and choose Book Creator from the toolbox menu in the right sidebar.", but those labels may have moved or been renamed. When the goal is met, verify it on screen. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
Proof · loop 1 failedaction · 15 cr · 64s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace
  2. click: Clicking Tools button
  3. wait: Waiting after checking for the element whose visible label is exactly 'Switch'.
The run stopped because its next required label, “Switch,” was not present in the open Tools menu.
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Tools
Kane's screenshot at the end of the proof · loop 1 run
Kane's screenshot at the end of this run, from its sealed evidence pack
Follow these steps literally, one at a time, from the current page. Click only what each step names. Never type a URL, search, or take another route. Where to find them, in the tutorial's own words: "Open Tools → Switch and click Special:Book Book." 1. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Tools'. 2. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Switch'. 3. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Special:Book Book'. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
Proof · loop 2 failedaction · 16.3 cr · 69s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace
  2. click: Clicking Tools button
  3. wait: Waiting after checking the open Tools menu
The run stopped because the test looked for a menu item named exactly “Switch,” but the current menu used a different label.
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Tools
Kane's screenshot at the end of the proof · loop 2 run
Kane's screenshot at the end of this run, from its sealed evidence pack
Follow these steps literally, one at a time, from the current page. Click only what each step names. Never type a URL, search, or take another route. Where to find them, in the tutorial's own words: "Open Tools, then Switch, and click Special:Book Book." 1. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Tools'. 2. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Switch'. 3. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Special:Book Book'. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
Proof · loop 3 failedaction · 11 cr · 50s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace
  2. click: Clicking Tools button
  3. wait: Waiting after checking for the element whose visible label is exactly 'Switch'
The run expected a Tools-menu item named “Switch,” but this page presents “Switch to legacy parser” instead.
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Tools
Kane's screenshot at the end of the proof · loop 3 run
Kane's screenshot at the end of this run, from its sealed evidence pack
Follow these steps literally, one at a time, from the current page. Click only what each step names. Never type a URL, search, or take another route. Where to find them, in the tutorial's own words: "Open Tools, then Switch, and click Special:Book Book." 1. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Tools'. 2. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Switch'. 3. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Special:Book Book'. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
2Next browse to any Wikipedia page and click the “Add this page to your book” link to include that article into your ebook.accurate
VerdictThe literal pass failed once, but the route Kane found is the doc's own route. Treated as a flaky run, not drift.
What Kane did
Literal failedaction · 12.1 cr · 39s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Book
  2. wait: Waiting after checking for the requested link
The check looked for an article-specific link while the browser was still on the Book Creator management page.
Follow these steps literally, one at a time, from the current page. Click only what each step names. Never type a URL, search, or take another route. Where to find them, in the tutorial's own words: "Next browse to any Wikipedia page and click the “Add this page to your book” link to include that article into your ebook." 1. Click the element whose visible label is exactly 'Add this page to your book'. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.
Goal passedtesting · 37.1 cr · 180s
  1. navigate: Navigate to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Book
  2. click: Clicking Suggest pages link
  3. wait: queued plan (2 steps): type "Search Wikipedia"; click "Search"
  4. type: Type "Earth" into "Search Wikipedia"
  5. click: Clicking Earth third planet from the Sun in search dropdown
  6. click: Clicking Add this page to your book in the book creator toolbar
  7. analyze: the page you end on has a main heading
  8. assert: the current article is added to a book on screen
  9. analyze: it is stored as {{landed_on}}
  10. wait: Waiting after successfully storing landed_on
  11. wait: Waiting after all book-addition checkpoints have passed
added the Earth article to a book on Wikipedia
Clicked, per the evidence pack: Suggest pages → Earth third planet → Add this page
Goal: the current article is added to a book. Reach it from the current page by clicking through the visible UI, by any route. Never type a URL or use the address bar. Hint: an old tutorial said "Next browse to any Wikipedia page and click the “Add this page to your book” link to include that article into your ebook.", but those labels may have moved or been renamed. When the goal is met, verify it on screen. If the page you end on has a main heading, store it as 'landed_on'; a page without a heading is fine.